More than any other footballer he seems to have sprung from the serious imagination of a child. The world he belongs to is not the rough, touchy, deceiving world of grown-up risks and chances but a world of lucid justice and simplicity. And just as a child’s prayerbook suggests a high-up fairness in the external order of things, a cloudlike God at the roof of the cosmos dispensing rewards to the virtuous, so his career seems to have unfolded at the center of a halo inside which blessings fall on those who deserve them, power emanates from wisdom, and the beautiful is a manifestation of the good.
Now, there’s a sense in which football is always giving off intimations of this sort of world, and in that sense the feeling it gives us resembles not so much a childish sense of right as a peasant’s consent to hierarchy, doomed to exalt the bearers of an unfathomable grace. There’s a danger in that feeling, which may explain why, in a democracy, the press is always set against footballers and against that exaltation—the more angrily and vulgarly against it the more of the people the press styles itself to be. So in a way the innocence of football is cowed on both sides and awakens a terrific resentment. But in Maldini’s case none of that seems to apply. He’s simply permitted a space of innocence, as if the system needed one true shining prince, as a bathtub drain, so to speak.

Fancifully, because who knows whether philosophy matters to the body’s moving parts, I’ve always thought it was this forthrightness, this way of living directly and without the frictions and reverses of a life of unclear purpose, that accounted for his amazing longevity. At almost 41 he plays like a 28-year-old and looks permanently established in the main of light. He made his first senior start for Milan on the day Ronald Reagan was sworn in for his second term in office, two weeks before the current king of derided tabloid idols was even born. Cristiano Ronaldo was named after Ronald Reagan, whom his father adored, but Maldini (whose middle name is Cesare, his father’s name) was named after a dynasty. And belongs to one.
His retirement, which is now only days away, strikes me as having an actual tragedy in it, because it’s the one accommodation he’s ever had to make to the indifference of the world to meaning. If meaning were everything he could go on playing forever, racing marvelously down the left side of the pitch to pluck the ball from attackers half his age, keeping his cool and keeping his team alert to the objective. But meaning has no purchase on the sinews, and virtue has no existence in the physical world, and he, too, will be tossed upon rough seas. His pace is already gone, and his unassuming lightness of touch, always so strange and breathtaking in a defender as powerful as he was, would only be a little easier to sustain than the strength that, through innumerable scuffles, supported it.
And the tragedy of this is that his growing old gives the lie to the vision of the world that his career almost made us believe in. Beauty isn’t goodness and power isn’t wisdom, even if, in the world’s haphazard mergings, they might briefly coexist. Blessings are arbitrary, even if they sometimes fall where they’re deserved. Still, illusory though it may have been, the fullness of the congruence he achieved made him a consolation, and we’ll remember him for that, and it will color what we mean when we say he was better at what he did than anyone who ever played the game. Almost without trying, he made us perceive a world that was better than the world we knew.
Read More: Milan, Paolo Maldini, Portraits
by Brian Phillips · May 12, 2009
god damn, it’s good to see you, The Tuesday Portrait.
If I remember Maldini as a young promising player along Baresi, is that a true sign that I’m not young anymore ?
“He’s simply permitted a space of innocence, as if the system needed one true shining prince, as a bathtub drain, so to speak.”
This is incredible.
upon re-reading, I’m convinced that someone needs to translate this to Italian, so that the man himself can read it. The last paragraph gave me shivers.
I find it absolutely astounding that this man has been so blessed, and carries this knowledge with such utter grace that, despite logic dictating otherwise, he seems utterly infallible.
I’m also amazed that I was an infant of two months when he made his debut. Just another reminder that, yes, I am an adult.
Brilliant writing, Brian–I hope to be as articulate and poignant a writer as this in the future.
beautiful article, beautiful football this man played. He will be missed.
Maldini always struck me as the Lampard or Italy; maybe that should be the other way around. Thanks for shedding a new light on him.
Oh, Brian. This is probably not a good thing, but you’ve pulled me out of retirement by writing this. Often there’s so little that is beautiful or even really good about loyalty, especially after a quarter-century – it begins to take on a quality of servitude and seems to demonstrate a lack of curiosity. You have to have be a career optimist – which, in his case, is a mixture of grit and wilful blindness, like we’ve all been about something we loved, at some point of time or other – to be in his story. To be an optimist for twenty-five years is amazing. I’m going to miss him so very much.
Also, watching him choke Chiellini this weekend was very surprising.
[The Lampard of Italy! I am curious as to what this signifies.]
The Lampard – Maldini comparison is that they both come from footballing pedigree and seem a product of that pedigree. They seem like they were fast forwarded here from an older footballing culture, maybe because they were raised by men from that culture. Both are willing and capable to take on whatever role the manager assigns them. They’re diligent and humble, even while other superstars ignite around them. They were raised to lead and carry the leadership of their clubs and countries, and do it with a certain ease from knowing they were born for the role (although the Lampard – Gerrard schism is a study in what manifestations of talent and leadership is valued in England).
Basically the whole good son / soldier thing, without many of the ill effects that can come with it.
I see that. I think this is one of those cases where the degree to which those roles are adopted/accommodated differ a lot: just the fact that Maldini’s career has stretched out through so many eras of football changes his position; he wasn’ ff’ed, he actually *is* that old.
It’d be interesting to see more of how Lampard’s difference from Gerrard has impacted his place in the captaincy tradition, of their own acceptance of power/responsibility [forgive the Spiderman reference, it's late here!] and their audiences’ comfort with their assuming it. Part of Maldini’s uniqueness is the strange lack of criticism surrounding his persona. It’s not that he’s resistant to it, he just doesn’t seem to invite it at all, from anyone – when Brian talks about that aura of innocence surrounding him, he talks about a universal phenomenon, not jut one specific to those of us who love Milan, or Italian defenders.
Great stuff Brian – I’ve always seen Maldini as the Willy Wonka of soccer, his smile holding a key to the inner joy of play when a game is a game (but incredibly successful).
A lovely elucidation of this football icon’s significance, Brian. Very well done.
The Gods have certainly put a fountain of magical ink in your pen. Your flair for writing is as spell-bounding as a Ronaldo step-over. Thanks for putting words to a career that actually do the player justice.
Onto the sunset…may we all have such an impact on our world.
Roswitha — So nice to see you out of retirement. Now please don’t go back into it!
I think you’re absolutely right about the optimism behind Maldini’s loyalty. And this may be getting at some part of the reason that he’s so beloved, because it’s an optimism that seems to be balanced by a kind of serene realism about himself. That is, the “curiosity” that underlies the transfers of many less loyal players seems to be less a desire for new scenes and more an eagerness to start over amid fresh vistas of flattery. If you spend a few years in Manchester, then you can’t help but have a sense that the management is aware of your weaknesses as well as your strengths. But here’s Real Madrid, swearing that you have no weaknesses and singing lullabies about your strengths.
The transfer market provides an endless series of opportunities for talented players to delude themselves about the extent of their own marvelousness. But Maldini seems to have no need for that kind of delusion, while also having an amazing ability to see the best in his current surroundings. To be an optimist about the world and a realist about oneself is to be a very rare creature, I think, especially among people with as many natural advantages as Maldini, and it’s not hard to see how a person like that would win affection without the corresponding resentment.
Colin — I have to admit, I almost dislocated my jaw when I saw that comparison, but your explanation makes sense. The fact that it was initially so startling probably says something about how hard it is to escape the media caricature of Lampard, even if (like me) you don’t agree with it. I assumed you were mocking Maldini!
Kudos for the guy responsible of writing this amazing article. If it describes anything about Paolo, it describes his awesome qualities on the pitch; for once I have read an article that doesn’t speak only about Maldini’s great defending skills, and now I’m surely impressed.
Maldini is one of the few players out there that can truly represent a club; such a legend. Thanks Maldini for those amazing year, although I barely have seen much from you, but the words that ring in my ear day in – day out have surely marked your amazing abilities in my heart.
The Roma match will be a hard one to swallow, mainly because it’s going to be your last San Siro match, but for every good thing there is an end…and as much as I hate to say this, you’re going to retire Maldini. Bye Bye Il Capitano!
You are pretty amazing, Brian, creatively certainly (this is another brilliant piece); but, I’m more amazed in this case by your acceptance and empathy.
My jaw remains dislocated, my head remains rammed through a wall, my typing undertaken on a keyboard currently lodged in my monitor on the Lampard-Maldini analogy. Myth making (and believing) of the highest order.
Thank you for a gift of of an article. Funny that you mentioned Manchester in your comments, as it is well known that Maldini id Sir Alex Ferguson’s favourite player to have played in the Champions League. Or maybe ever.
Now what princely gifts should I offer in return for a compare / contrast piece on Ryan Giggs?
I was a Primary school student when I first heard of maldini in the late eighties. am now in my early thirties having worked for 7 years after university, and he has been there through all that time.
Wow, what a player. Thanks for all the years of Soccer, Paolo. enjoy your retirement.
this blog is my #1 favorite blog to read, i really really really enjoy it. even though my visits are usually inconsistent, but i cover all.
this reading was a true joy, the man who i followed since i was 6 years for 15 years and suddenly its only a shadow.
keep up the good work, this is also truly amazing while smoking some nice green
to elate your senses and appreciate even more.
One of the finest pieces of sports writing I have ever read. How fitting that it be dedicated to the greatest player of the last 25 years.
“But meaning has no purchase on the sinews, and virtue has no existence in the physical world”
CARTESIAN HERESY!!!
A Cesare never fades away, thank you Paolo for your grace and cerebral landscape to play this game.