The Bissinger Video

Here’s the tape of the Buzz Bissinger-Will Leitch contretemps. Watching it again, I wish Leitch had answered more directly in a couple of places (there are some moments that sound like spin, and he seemed to feel that with Braylon Edwards there he couldn’t simply admit that his comedy site mocks athletes). But it was also pretty astonishing to see Buzz Bissinger essentially accuse Leitch of exploiting athletes’ private lives for his own gain. I wonder if anyone in Odessa, Texas ever thought they knew a sportswriter who did that?

Parenthetically—and then I’ll go back to writing about soccer, I promise—I’d like to point out that the religion of the old-time sportswriters that Bissinger starts to proclaim here has gotten a little out of hand. Someday I’ll actually write that essay about Hemingway’s influence on sportswriting and the pulps and its decisive effect on twentieth-century American vernacular. Till then, I’ll just say that despite Bissinger’s contention that bloggers don’t care about sentences, I care about them intensely, much more than I care about sports, and W.C. Heinz is not Virginia Woolf. “Death of a Racehorse” is a great blog post—under 1000 words, written in two hours—but it’s a third-rate piece of literature, and far too easy to feel sentimental about.

Thanks to Awful Announcing for the clip.

5 comments
  • Notwithstanding Buzz’s (depressive) down, he misses the point about blogs — the blog share of eyeballs.

    Yes blogs of all varieties of quality steal traffic from hardworking, journalistic work (like Buzz is committed to). They even help corrupt the revenue streams of newspapers.

    But blog audiences who come back to the low-quality stuff or the inflammatory made-up stuff are not necessarily a natural audience for good writing.

    Also, with the web, it’s speed makes up for the lack of accuracy: if something is wrong — or superficial — we’ll see the correction just as quickly as the original factoid.

    That’s why I can trust Wikipedia for a quick fact-check (as far as I can throw it … which isn’t bad). Not all fact, rumor or bullshit is equal.

    The blog is partly about time-wasting entertainment. Until blogs there was nothing like them to fill that specific niche. Life isn’t always serious.

    Buzz lost perspective. Media is shifting. Let’s see where we land.

  • I don’t know who Buzz Bissinger is, nor do I know what Friday Night Lights is. But anyone who would go on a nationally broadcast television show and spout the vile language he used in an attempt to complain about the boorishness of some blogs is a hypocrite without compare.

  • Later in the segment he told Leitch that he looked like “Jimmy Olsen on Percocet.” Which is at least marginally clever, though as it came moments after he accused “blogs” of being “glib,” it didn’t do much to combat the impression of hypocrisy.

    Friday Night Lights is a book about high-school football in Odessa, Texas (American football, obviously) that shows how the town’s obsession with its team reveals deep-seated social and economic tensions. It got made into an unpopular American TV show in which attractive people in their mid-20s credibly play interesting teenagers.

  • One has to give Buzz some credit for some considered contrition: http://thebiglead.com/?p=5684

  • Tom, absolutely; I’m putting together a post on this as we speak. I still disagree strongly with a lot of Bissinger’s opinions—why should sports blogs have to be “information-based”?—but full credit to him for acknowledging his mistakes and apologizing.

Your comment